4.8 Stars - Based on 796 Customer Reviews

Leaf Filter vs. LeafGuard: A Comprehensive Comparison of Gutter Guards 

November 8, 2023

Gutter protection is a pivotal aspect of home maintenance that safeguards against water damage and eliminates the time-consuming task of gutter cleaning. With the myriad of options available, choosing the best gutter guard can be challenging. Among the popular gutter guard brands are Leaf Filter and Leaf Guard. In this comprehensive guide, we will dissect these two top gutter guard providers to help homeowners decide which system aligns with their home needs.

Understanding Gutter Protection

Before diving into the specifics of Leafguard and Leaffilter, it's crucial to comprehend the importance of a gutter guard system. Not only do these systems prevent clogging from leaves and debris, but they also extend the life of your gutters, reduce the need for frequent gutter cleanings, and improve the flow of water away from your home's foundation.

GutterGuard: What You Need to Know

Gutter guards are pivotal in avoiding debris accumulation and ensuring the longevity of your existing gutter system. There are various gutter guard types out there—from screens and foams to micro-mesh and reverse curve options. The right choice for your home will depend on several factors, like climate, foliage, and gutter compatibility.

The In-Depth Overview of Leaf Filter

History and Functionality

LeafFilter began its journey in the gutter protection market with a focus on providing a hassle-free gutter system. The LeafFilter system utilizes a stainless steel micro-mesh filter that is designed to lock out all types of debris, making it one of the best options for fine filtration.

Key Advantages:

  • No clogs guarantee
  • Fits snugly onto existing gutters
  • Lifetime transferable warranty

Potential Drawbacks:

  • Higher upfront costs
  • Professional installation is recommended
  • Periodic maintenance to ensure top performance

Installation Process:

  1. Assessment of existing gutters
  2. Preparation and cleaning
  3. Installation of the Leaffilter gutter guards by certified professionals


LeafFilter gutter guards are designed to handle even the heaviest of rainfalls, managing up to 32 inches of rain per hour without overflows.

An Inside Look at Leaf Guard

Brand Heritage and Operation

LeafGuard offers a patented one-piece gutter system that promises a permanent solution to gutter clogs. It features a built-in hood that covers the gutter, allowing water to roll over the curved edge while blocking debris.


  • Custom-fit to current gutters
  • No-clog guarantee that could lead to a free gutter cleaning
  • Aesthetic appeal without visible brackets or hangers

Potential Cons:

  • May require a complete gutter replacement
  • Limited color and style options
  • Single-unit design can be costly

Installation Overview:

Professionally crafted and built, LeafGuard gutters are designed on-site to fit perfectly with your existing gutter system, ensuring a seamless integration.

Performance Expectations:

With its unique design, the LeafGuard system allows water into the gutter while efficiently shedding debris, all backed by a Good Housekeeping Seal of approval.

Side-by-Side Comparison


Leaf FilterLeaf Guard
Adapts to existing guttersReplaces old gutters

Performance and Maintenance:

In terms of maintenance, Leaffilter warranty offers peace of mind, while LeafGuard simplifies the process with its one-piece design. Both claim to ease your gutter cleaning tasks significantly.

Cost-Benefit Analysis:

Leaf Filter is known for its competitive pricing, but it is essential to consider the long-term cost savings associated with reduced maintenance and potential water damage prevention offered by both systems.

Customer Perspectives and Reviews

When weighing Leafguard vs. Leaffilter, one must consider customer reviews. Both brands boast numerous testimonies; however, they each shine and falter in different aspects according to the customer's experience.

Expert Opinions

Leafguard's one-piece system is generally favored for its strength, whereas Leaffilter's micro-mesh technology is praised for its filtering prowess.

Choosing the Best Gutter Guard for Your Home

Choosing between Leafguard or Leaffilter should be based on factors such as your regional climate, the types of foliage around your home, and your roof's pitch and compatibility with the gutter guard system.

  • Leafguard might be the better option if you're looking for a low-maintenance, durable solution in a region with heavy foliage.
  • For homes concerned with the smallest debris or in an area with fine plant matter like pine needles, Leaffilter and its micro-mesh technology could be ideal.


In our detailed comparison of Leaf Filter vs. Leaf Guard, we've explored the intricacies of each gutter guard brand to arm you with the knowledge needed to make the best choice for your home. We encourage you to consider the functional and financial aspects and to engage with gutter guard providers to find the perfect fit.

FAQ Section:

What Warranties do LeafGuard and LeafFilter Offer? 

Both LeafGuard and LeafFilter offer comprehensive warranties on their gutter protection systems. LeafGuard provides a lifetime guarantee on clogs or leaks, meaning they will fix any issues with their gutters for as long as you own your home. They also offer a 25-year paint finish warranty and a 20-year limited warranty on their installation. LeafFilter also offers a lifetime warranty on their gutter guard system, ensuring that it will effectively prevent clogs and debris buildup for the entire lifetime of your home.

How does the Leaffilter warranty compare to LeafGuard's? 

The LeafFilter warranty is a Lifetime Transferable Warranty that covers both the product and installation. It guarantees that the system will not clog or overflow and provides protection against defects and failures. On the other hand, LeafGuard offers a similar Lifetime Transferable Warranty that covers defects and faulty installation but does not guarantee against clogging or overflowing. 

What is the downside of LeafFilter?

One downside of LeafFilter is its initial high cost. The price of installation and materials can be expensive compared to other gutter protection options. Additionally, some customers have reported issues with the product not fitting properly or not effectively filtering debris. Regular maintenance and occasional cleaning may still be necessary, despite its claims of being maintenance-free. 

What is the downside of LeafGuard?

One downside of LeafGuard is that it can be quite expensive compared to traditional gutters. The cost of installation and materials can be higher due to the specialized design and installation process. Additionally, the limited availability of LeafGuard products may make it difficult to find a local installer, especially in rural areas. 

Is LeafGuard worth the money?

It really depends on your specific circumstances. LeafGuard can be worth the money if you live in an area with a lot of trees and experience frequent clogging in your gutters. The system's patented design helps prevent debris from entering your gutters, saving you time and effort on maintenance. However, if you don't have many trees around or rarely experience gutter clogging, you may not find the investment necessary. 

Get a Free Estimate

Get Free Estimate

600+ Customers Approve Us

Our Hassle-Free Process in 4 Easy Steps!

Step 1

Phone Consultation

When we speak with you over the phone, we'll listen to your needs to see if we're a good fit for your roofing project.
Step 2

Free Roof Estimate

Our Roof Estimators provide in-home or no-contact free estimates. We listen to your design needs and give you an honest, detailed quote.
Step 3

Roof Installation

Our Roofers treat your home as if it were their own and clean up afterwards.
Step 4

Customer Care

The IBEX Roof guarantee is backed by a commitment to making sure you are happy with your roof, or you don't pay a dime.

Not sure how much longer your roof will last?

Don't wait until your roof is completely falling apart.
Book a Free Estimate

Why Choose

At IBEX Roof, we strive to make your experience with us as straightforward and stress-free as possible. We’ll explain everything in detail and provide an exact estimate for your project. We’ll show up on time, keep disruptions to your home and property to a minimum, and make sure you’re happy with our work once we’re finished.
We are True Roofing Experts.
Sure-Footed. Honest. Professional.
We have spent years in residential roofing and commercial roofing work—always with an eye on improving our process.
We believe in quality. That starts with the roofing materials we use on every job; continues in the methods of safe, efficient working standards we employ for our team and continues right down to the experience we create for our clients.
We’re in this for the long haul, and we know that just isn’t possible by producing sub-standard work or creating poor working relationships.

The roofing profession isn’t known for offering the best customer service experience. We’re here to change that by setting a new industry standard.
IBEX Roof's square logo representing their roofing services in Vancouver, WA
Washington State License: IBEXRRL850KG
Oregon State License: 207308
© 2023 www.ibexroof.com. "We're on TOP of it"